Proper Tea for Proper Blokes: Why the Artisanal Coffee Shop is Ruining Britain

← Essays & Articles

Right, somebody has to say it, and frankly I'm amazed the local council hasn't put up warning signs outside these places yet. There is an appalling shift happening on our high streets, and you don't need a degree in sociology to spot it. Walk down any town centre on a Saturday morning, pass a proper greasy spoon, and then look across the road at the glass-fronted establishment with exposed brickwork and three fixed-gear bicycles parked outside. The evidence is everywhere. Proper blokes drink builder's tea, while modern gents pay mortgages for milk that's been whipped into the shape of a fern.

I appreciate that some people will immediately start complaining about choice, modern lifestyle, and all that hipster nonsense. That's perfectly understandable, but it doesn't alter what is plainly happening in front of us. You can write as many angry posts on Instagram as you like, but eventually you still have to explain why a man needs a wooden board, half a squashed avocado, and a tiny cup of lukewarm brown water to survive until lunchtime.

The Greasy Spoon: The Engine Room of the Nation

The traditional British café is not merely an eatery. It is a sanctuary of common sense. Everything about it suggests industrial reliability. Formica tables that have survived four recessions, a condensation-covered counter displaying individual slices of Victoria sponge, and a kettle the size of an oil drum. That is the general philosophy of the greasy spoon. If a meal can be served with a side of thick bread and butter and a mug of tea dark enough to stain mahogany, the roadside café will happily provide it.

This is exactly what a proper bloke wants. A mug of builder's tea looks as though it could jump-start a diesel transit van in the dead of winter. You can stir two spoons of white sugar into it, lean against a cold brick wall, and contemplate the state of the roads without once having to consider the ethical origin of the tea leaf.

There is also the food situation. In a proper café, a breakfast arrives on a plate large enough to be used as a shield in a medieval siege. Two eggs, four bangers, a mound of hash browns, and beans forming a natural moat around the fried bread. You eat it, you wipe your mouth with a paper napkin from a dispenser that dispenses three hundred at once, and you carry on with your day.

Then We Come to the Artisanal Coffee Emporium

Now, the modern coffee shop is obviously a very different proposition. There is no point pretending otherwise. An "artisanal roast house" has its own particular way of doing things, which seems to involve bare concrete floors, metal stools specifically engineered to cause lower back pain, and music that sounds like a lawnmower stuck in a tumble dryer.

The hipster gentleman approaches breakfast rather differently too. While the traditional chap is contemplating whether he wants extra black pudding, the espresso connoisseur is engaged in a lengthy negotiation with a twenty-two-year-old barista in an apron about "tasting notes" and whether the milk was gently whispered to by an oat farmer in Sussex.

Then there is the coffee itself. A proper mug of tea allows a man to hold something substantial with both hands. The artisanal "Flat White," on the other hand, comes in a vessel roughly the size of a thimble. You are expected to sit on a micro-stool, holding this fragile porcelain cup with two fingers, looking for all the world as though you are playing a child's tea party set in a Scandinavian showroom.

And there is absolutely nothing wrong with that, of course. A man is perfectly entitled to spend £4.50 on eighty millilitres of dark liquid that tastes subtly of burnt lemons while sitting on an overturned milk crate. That is his business. I merely question whether it should be described as nourishment.

The Matter of the Toast

This is where the difference becomes particularly absurd. A proper British café understands toast. It arrives white, thick, dripping with salted butter, and stacked like building blocks beside a fried egg.

The coffee emporium, however, serves sourdough. Sourdough is not bread; it is a construction material. It requires a serrated saw, immense physical effort, and the jaw strength of an alligator to chew through. On top of this wooden plank, they smear a crushed avocado—a fruit that looks like a hand grenade and tastes like damp grass—and charge you the equivalent of a second-hand lawnmower for the privilege.

The tea drinker gets a full breakfast and a refill for six quid. The coffee hipster gets a slice of hard crust and a dollop of green paste for fifteen pounds. The tea drinker has put in a full day's manual labor by midday. The coffee hipster has spent forty minutes trying to connect his laptop to the Wi-Fi.

That, to my mind, is the distinction.

The Great British Beverage Divide

Of course, coffee enthusiasts will insist that their beverage is all about "flavor profiles," "single-origin beans," and "complexity." Fair enough. I'm sure it is very rewarding to sit under a filament light bulb discussing the acidic balance of a Ethiopian roast for forty-five minutes before taking two tiny sips.

The builder's tea crowd, meanwhile, tend to have a slightly different understanding of refreshment. Their idea of a good morning is filling a stainless-steel flask at 6:00 AM, driving sixty miles up the M1, and drinking it out of a plastic cup on the tailgate of a pickup truck in torrential rain. Tea is built for that sort of behavior. It functions equally well whether served in a chipped mug or a pint glass, provided it is hot enough to strip paint off a doorframe.

The coffee gentleman, meanwhile, has probably brought an oat-milk alternative.

The Final Verdict

So perhaps we should stop pretending that every breakfast establishment serves exactly the same function. Obviously, people can eat and drink whatever they like, and I'm sure there are perfectly respectable coffee drinkers who occasionally do an honest day's work. There are probably even tea drinkers who have accidentally wandered into an artisanal cafe when they couldn't find a Greggs.

But that rather spoils the theory, and I'm not prepared to let facts get in the way of a perfectly good argument.

A proper mug of tea remains, in my completely impartial and scientifically verified opinion, the culinary equivalent of an anvil. It is heavy, honest, completely immune to fashion, and best consumed alongside a piece of fried bread that could float a small boat.

The artisanal coffee house is something else entirely. It is beard oil, potted succulents, acoustic indie music, and pretension, generally accompanied by a man who has spent considerably more time talking about his coffee than actually drinking it.

So the next time you're walking down the high street looking for a morning pick-me-up, have a look at what's happening through the windows. The tea bloke will probably be finishing a third sausage and preparing to move a mountain, while the coffee bloke will be waiting for his milk foam to settle so he can take a photo of it.

And if there happens to be a small pile of crushed avocado sitting on an indestructible piece of sourdough, don't say I didn't warn you.

The evidence is simply overwhelming.

Well, overwhelming if you ignore anything that contradicts it.